Page 1 of 1

Review: Street Hot Rod (Magic Makers)

Posted: June 4th, 2018, 5:08 am
by EndersGame
Street Hot Rod (Magic Makers)

An over-sized and light-weight metal version of a classic trick!

Overview

The Hot Rod is a well known classic of magic, and it's been around long enough that there are a lot of different versions of it available on the market. This particular one is a premium one made out of metal, in a larger-than-normal size, to ensure durability, visibility, and a quality and professional look.

Many consider the Hot Rod trick well suited for "advanced beginners", which means that newcomers to magic can certainly learn it, if they are willing to learn and perfect the paddle move that is at the heart of this trick.

Image

Contents

This product comes in a sealed plastic bag, which includes a high quality metal hot rod, which is made out of polished light-weight yet solid aluminium. It has six brightly painted recessed circles, featuring white, yellow, blue, red, green, and black; with six red circles on the reverse.

A cardboard insert gives instructions about how the effect works, with the majority of the explanation describing how to do the paddle move. The printed instructions also include a link to a secret page on the publisher's website that gives you free access to an online teaching video.

Image

Effect

First you show your spectator that your metal Hot Rod has has six colored dots on each side. Your spectator then freely selects a number from one to six, and you use this to count to a particular dot, asking them to remember its colour. Then with a simple wave, all the dots on the Hot Rod magically turn into that colour - on both sides! The original colours can be restored, although alternate ways of ending the trick are also possible.

See a simple performance of the Hot Rod illusion by Ben Salinas, using this particular product, in a short video clip here:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vbf-EgJYn_8

Image

Here's an alternative video trailer, which has ridiculously high production values, and features Rob Stiff demonstrating the effect.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7x8ZXUbqkUI

Teaching

While you can certainly learn this trick from the printed materials provided, the paddle move really is best learned visually, so I really appreciated the fact that besides the step-by-step written instructions you also get access to online video teaching. A couple of different camera angles are used, with an over-the-head shot used for most of the video, which ensures that everything can be followed very clearly.

The explanation video is eight minutes long and has Rob explaining the two main elements of the routine, namely the force and the paddle move, including tips for how to master the paddle move, and different ways to approach it. He also offers several suggestions for different ways to end the routine, including a method where you can allow spectators to examine it.

Image

Difficulty

This trick really isn't very difficult to do, and so there's good reason it has remained a popular favourite in the magic industry. In terms of the skills required to do it, there is a simple force that is used, and you'll need to be very familiar with the six outcomes so that you can produce the result you need easily and naturally.

The most important thing to be mastered, however, is the paddle move, and while it's not difficult, it shouldn't be rushed into performance either. But this trick is certainly an excellent introduction to this concept, and for most people this move will be relatively easy to learn. From that point it's just a matter of being totally comfortable with both the force and the paddle move, so that you can focus on making the presentation interesting.

Image

Recommendation

Don't let the simplicity of this trick deceive you into underestimating its impact. Especially when seen close-up for the first time, it can really generate astonishment. And because it's not inherently difficult, it's ideal for beginner magicians, while still remaining an evergreen classic that the experienced magician can still use as well. The video instructions do a good job of explaining everything, and also emphasize the importance of mastering the paddle move before performing.

The larger-than-normal size of the Hot Rod is nice, because it ensures that the colours can easily be seen, and it is an attractive and quality metal product that conveys professionalism.

Good presentation, plus mastering the technical aspect of the performance, are essential as always. But when done well, this simple trick really does have the potential to amaze. With the Street Hot Rod, you'll get everything you need to get you on your way to achieving that!

Image

Want to learn more? See:
- Publisher's page
- Amazon
- Older thread about the history of the Hot Rod

Re: Review: Street Hot Rod (Magic Makers)

Posted: June 4th, 2018, 6:38 am
by Jack Shalom
Paddle force...ugh.

Better to size up the spec and give each color an attribute (e.g. love, anger, honesty, sexiness, confusion, intelligence) with the required color given the attribute they would most likely choose.

Re: Review: Street Hot Rod (Magic Makers)

Posted: June 4th, 2018, 8:16 am
by Q. Kumber
The best routine for Hot Rod, that I have come across, is Leslie Melville's from his book, Magictales 2. He combines it with another, similar trick, making a strong, entertaining, baffling presentation, and there's no force anywhere.

Re: Review: Street Hot Rod (Magic Makers)

Posted: June 4th, 2018, 8:36 am
by Anthony Vinson
Jack Shalom wrote:Paddle force...ugh.


Yeah, my thoughts exactly. At least those were my thoughts a year ago, but after being schooled by a couple of magician friends, I have developed a new appreciation for some of those old chestnuts, including paddle tricks. Hot Rod plays amazingly well for general laypeople, and as an amateur who performs strictly for the fun, amusement, and amazement of general laypeople, that means a lot. I have also returned to the silly foil-embossed cards for Color Monte after decades of performing it with regular cards. Again, for general laypeople it plays amazingly well. For pros or semi-pros, and perhaps those who aspire to be such, perhaps these sorts of tricks won't resonate. For lifelong amateurs and lovers of fun, I would suggest getting back in touch with some of the older "slum" magic tricks. You might be surprised. I was.

Av

Re: Review: Street Hot Rod (Magic Makers)

Posted: June 4th, 2018, 8:55 am
by Edward Pungot
I must have sold thousands of hot rods and color montes demo ed them to death at the Knotts Berry Farm magic shop. [Retired]

It's still a mystery to me why these simple tricks work and sell as they do.

Re: Review: Street Hot Rod (Magic Makers)

Posted: June 4th, 2018, 11:45 am
by EndersGame
I'm curious how others end this routine - what do you think of the idea of 'painting' just one side red after showing both sides restored as coloured, and then handing it out for examination?

Re: Review: Street Hot Rod (Magic Makers)

Posted: June 4th, 2018, 12:36 pm
by Richard Kaufman
Enders Game: I appreciate your reviews posted here, but please use some common sense when reviewing something as simple and well known as "Hot Rod" for a group of magicians. Your review could have been, at most, two short paragraphs and we would have known all there was to know.

Re: Review: Street Hot Rod (Magic Makers)

Posted: June 4th, 2018, 3:52 pm
by Brad Jeffers
EndersGame wrote: what do you think of the idea of 'painting' just one side red after showing both sides restored as coloured, and then handing it out for examination?

A terrible idea, probably thought up by a dealer so the ad copy could say that the rod could be "handed out for examination".

Re: Review: Street Hot Rod (Magic Makers)

Posted: June 4th, 2018, 5:10 pm
by Roger M.
I'm not sure any company has ever done more to rip off creators than Magic Makers have.
But as noted above, do we really need a review of a Hot Rod in this forum? ... I mean really ... a Hot Rod?

I also take issue with the burgeoning multitude of "magic reviewers" who have tag lines similar to this in every single one of their web posts:

"Want me to write a review of your playing cards or magic? Contact me via Private Message."

This is a new cottage industry that involves Magic Makers (for example) sending the reviewer an endless stream of free products, which the reviewer then places a "review" of in every possible magic forum they can find:

Here's this identical review in the Cafe:
http://www.themagiccafe.com/forums/view ... c=667092#0

And again in the Theory 11 forums:
https://www.theory11.com/forums/threads ... ers.52018/

The end result of this is a bunch of free advertising for Magic Makers, and a bunch of free products for the reviewer.
It's a joke really. And it's most definitely not a review ... it's really just spam.

Re: Review: Street Hot Rod (Magic Makers)

Posted: June 4th, 2018, 8:05 pm
by EndersGame
Richard Kaufman wrote:Enders Game: I appreciate your reviews posted here, but please use some common sense when reviewing something as simple and well known as "Hot Rod" for a group of magicians. Your review could have been, at most, two short paragraphs and we would have known all there was to know.

That's a fair point, Mr Kaufman, especially given the readership here. I'll take that on board for the future.

I really enjoyed reading through this older thread from 2002 on the Genii Forum, where there is some terrific discussion about the history and origins of the Hot Rod. Undoubtedly we are all familiar with the Hot Rod concept, but how many of us know who actually came up with it, and when? It appears to have been in the very early 1970s, and I've seen some attribute it to Jack Miller, while others attribute it to Jim Zee. Ken Allen's "Jumping Gems" from the 1950s is arguably a related ancestor.

As for presentation, Robert Kane has shared a nice approach (here) he uses that was inspired by a Michael Skinner presentation as published in Genii in November 2000. Skinner's routine, "Liberace's Piano Keys", introduces the rods as piano keys given by Liberace. Robert runs with the idea of the hot rod being an ancient jewellers stick.

A similar idea (here) from Steve Dusheck uses a plot revolving around lucky zodiac gems. He suggests a wonderful idea (here) of personalizing the trick by using a spectators zodiac sign, and he also came up with a zodiac force that could be used instead of the somewhat awkward spelling force. Peter Marucci also suggested an alternative force in his routine "The Gypsy Rod" (published in Linking Ring, February 2003), but this only employs five instead of all six colours.

Evidently there are mixed feelings about the One-to-Six/Spelling Force. Who invented it? One source (here) suggests that Alan Smithee claims ownership of this idea.

Re: Review: Street Hot Rod (Magic Makers)

Posted: June 4th, 2018, 8:40 pm
by Edward Pungot
Lol.
What a riot of a thread.
The Skinner reference was a nice touch.
Drama. Gotta love it.

Re: Review: Street Hot Rod (Magic Makers)

Posted: June 4th, 2018, 10:33 pm
by Bill Mullins
EndersGame wrote:Evidently there are mixed feelings about the One-to-Six/Spelling Force. Who invented it? One source (here) suggests that Alan Smithee claims ownership of this idea.


"Alan Smithee" is a made-up name that film directors use when they want to disown a movie that would otherwise carry their name (perhaps because the studio recut it into something horrible).

So the source you link to is suggesting that the One-to-Six/Spelling Force is so crappy that no one would claim it (an opinion that has much to recommend it -- what kind of moron says "Give me a number from one to six," you give him "two", he says "Oh good, Two has 3 letters," and then counts to three?)

Re: Review: Street Hot Rod (Magic Makers)

Posted: June 5th, 2018, 3:57 pm
by Q. Kumber
Does anyone know a source for having custom Hot Rods made?

Re: Review: Street Hot Rod (Magic Makers)

Posted: June 5th, 2018, 4:47 pm
by Chris Aguilar
Roger M. wrote:I'm not sure any company has ever done more to rip off creators than Magic Makers have.
But as noted above, do we really need a review of a Hot Rod in this forum? ... I mean really ... a Hot Rod?

I also take issue with the burgeoning multitude of "magic reviewers" who have tag lines similar to this in every single one of their web posts:

"Want me to write a review of your playing cards or magic? Contact me via Private Message."

This is a new cottage industry that involves Magic Makers (for example) sending the reviewer an endless stream of free products, which the reviewer then places a "review" of in every possible magic forum they can find:

...

The end result of this is a bunch of free advertising for Magic Makers, and a bunch of free products for the reviewer.
It's a joke really. And it's most definitely not a review ... it's really just spam.


Agreed and agreed. Especially with these "Reviews" being larded with ad text and other bits and pieces that add exactly... nothing.

These "reviews" are bloated to the point that I can honestly say that I've never had the patience to get completely through even one of them.

Spam's a pretty good descriptor here.

Re: Review: Street Hot Rod (Magic Makers)

Posted: September 13th, 2018, 10:39 pm
by DaniStall
Once owned a set made by Peter Marucci that was very unique with velvet bags included.

Re: Review: Street Hot Rod (Magic Makers)

Posted: September 14th, 2018, 12:51 am
by Bill Mullins
I know there isn't really an answer to this question, but . . .

What is it that makes this a "street" hot rod? How would it be different if it weren't "street"?

Re: Review: Street Hot Rod (Magic Makers)

Posted: September 14th, 2018, 1:52 am
by EndersGame
Bill Mullins wrote:What is it that makes this a "street" hot rod? How would it be different if it weren't "street"?

It think it's just to distinguish it from a standard hot rod. This one is much bigger than normal, since it's more than 8 inches long.

Perhaps the idea is that it's more suitable for performing street magic to a larger group of people, and they can still all see what is going on?

But the term "Giant Hot Rod" would have worked just as well.

Re: Review: Street Hot Rod (Magic Makers)

Posted: September 14th, 2018, 4:50 am
by Q. Kumber
Since my previous posts, I've bought Hot Rod made by Rich Hill, pricey but fits brilliantly with the Leslie Melville routine I mentioned above, and there's no silly force in sight.

Re: Review: Street Hot Rod (Magic Makers)

Posted: September 14th, 2018, 10:54 am
by Bill Mullins
EndersGame wrote:But the term "Giant Hot Rod" would have worked just as well.


Only as a descriptive term. It would not be as successful as a marketing term, if you are targeting people who are inclined buy things because they are labeled "street".

I would have thought that such a group would be so small as to not justify branding products with it in mind. Yet . . .

Street Thief from Paul Harris
Street Monte from Sal Piacente
Street Monte from G. Sparks
Street Cups from Gazzo
Magnetic Street Shells from Whit Haydn and Chef Anton
Street Cents from Andrew Gerard
Street Casino from Axel Veldens
Multiplying Balls for the Street from Whit Haydn

Re: Review: Street Hot Rod (Magic Makers)

Posted: September 14th, 2018, 12:40 pm
by Matthew Field
This thing is eight inches long! Where are you supposed to carry it?

Re: Review: Street Hot Rod (Magic Makers)

Posted: September 14th, 2018, 1:29 pm
by Roger M.
Matthew Field wrote:This thing is eight inches long! Where are you supposed to carry it?

I would also seriously question just how "deceptive" the paddle move is with what is essentially something getting close to the size of an actual paddle!

Re: Review: Street Hot Rod (Magic Makers)

Posted: September 14th, 2018, 9:36 pm
by EndersGame
Matthew Field wrote:This thing is eight inches long! Where are you supposed to carry it?

Along with your Street Cups and Balls, Street Linking Rings, and Street Playing Cards, in your over-sized Street Knapsack.

Re: RE: Re: Review: Street Hot Rod (Magic Makers)

Posted: September 19th, 2018, 5:02 pm
by Peirceman
Matthew Field wrote:This thing is eight inches long! Where are you supposed to carry it?
Oh dear, so many jokes, too new to the group to offend anyone...... Yet.

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

Re: Review: Street Hot Rod (Magic Makers)

Posted: September 19th, 2018, 6:24 pm
by Jack Shalom
Personally, I strap mine on. I get raves on my paddle move.

Re: Review: Street Hot Rod (Magic Makers)

Posted: September 19th, 2018, 9:22 pm
by Richard Kaufman
Jack ... I didn't know you were that kind of guy!

Re: Review: Street Hot Rod (Magic Makers)

Posted: September 20th, 2018, 12:27 am
by Jack Shalom
Finally, my wife is excited by my magic!

Hmmm...I better stop there...

Re: Review: Street Hot Rod (Magic Makers)

Posted: September 20th, 2018, 5:25 am
by Matthew Field
I worked for 5 or 6 years for a large New York City home furnishing department store as their advertising director. Some of my co-workers knew of my interest in magic and wold ask me to "show them something." I'm basically a card guy, so I carried several "pocket tricks" with me, one of which was Hot Rod. How to justify the prop?

I called it a jeweller's color sample, showing acceptable colors for diamonds, rubies, emeralds and other gems. I was never challenged. To force a color, I wrote down the colors on small pieces of paper and used the PATEO force. I disliked the standard Hot Rod force so much I once asked Pat Page if he could suggest an alternative. He did, but, honestly, I didn't like it at all. Neither did he.

My points are two: I carried the thing in my pocket, and I had a justification for the gems mounted in a stick. The new version fails in both regards.

Matt Field

Re: Review: Street Hot Rod (Magic Makers)

Posted: December 16th, 2018, 12:02 am
by Mr. Charming
To force the red color:

There is a type of joke/puzzle partially well known in spanish culture; I don't if there is the same thing in english culture. Basically, you ask a person in a more or less rapid pace: "What's the color of the snow? What's the color of clouds? What's the color of cotton? What does a cow drink?". Now if you do it correctly, they will say "Milk" however this is clearly a mistake since cows drink water, not milk (grown up cows of course). So it works like a "hack" in your brain, by making you answer "white" a few times and then playing with the assocition implicit between cow and milk.

Now in a similar vein, if you ask someone "How much is 5x5?" and then ask "Name a color" they will say "red". Try it and see. So you can say "We will eliminate 5 colors, how much would be 5x5?" and then ask for a color it will probably work (although there is no reason for the 5x5).

Re: Review: Street Hot Rod (Magic Makers)

Posted: December 16th, 2018, 1:04 am
by performer
Oddly enough I haven't the slightest idea what a hot rod or a colour monte trick is even though I have been doing magic for about 60 years or so. I will concede that I have heard about those tricks but I have no idea what they are supposed to do. So the reviews are welcome to me. Never make assumptions about what people know or don't know. Besides I suspect those particular tricks were invented after 1954 so that is probably why I don't know them.

Re: Review: Street Hot Rod (Magic Makers)

Posted: December 16th, 2018, 3:11 am
by Mr. Charming
I also didn't know what it was, although I certainly heard the name many times. I just never cared to know.

Re: Review: Street Hot Rod (Magic Makers)

Posted: December 16th, 2018, 10:54 am
by performer
I do two paddle tricks and that is quite enough for me. I do the Dotty Spots trick (which I suspect comes from Edward Victor although I can't be sure) and the Dr Sack Dice trick which has always stood me in good stead. I have carried them around with me virtually every day of my life since I was 16 years old. At least they fit in my pocket. That Hot Rod thing looks a bit too big for impromptu use.