Brad Henderson wrote:So - do we think the judges comments for Eric and rudy were accurate or off base?
I think within the known constraints of the competition, the judges comments were overly blunt, but essentially accurate. The acts really needed an editor for this competition.
Ninety seconds just isn't enough time to mess around, especially in such a large venue. The AGT audience is seeking hard hitting, quick spectacle. Anything that doesn't "Wow!" them immediately is most likely not going to make the cut.
It's like the difference between competition chili vs. something you might want to eat a whole bowl full of.