The gimmick I use is an old key with a large "eye". This has been wrapped in flesh colored band-aids to soften it in the hand. A slit is made over the "eye" for insertion of the target key.
Thus, the gimmick is almost invisible, it is soft and easy to work with, and SILENT.
hope this helps.
Creator of the famous "Floating Match On Card" illusion.
WOWBOUND.COM - INSTANT DOWNLOADS